The world is no stranger to bizarre celebrity baby names, from Gwyneth Paltrow’s “Apple” to Beyonce and Jay Z’s “Blue Ivy.” But there’s one couple who just might hold the title for the oddest baby name of all time: Jay and Kateri Schwandt.

As parents to a growing brood of 14 sons, the Schwandts had their hearts set on adding a little girl to the mix. However, fate had other plans for them. When their 14th child arrived, it was yet another bouncing baby boy, weighing 8lb and 4 ounces. They named him Finley, but they wanted something special for his middle name.

Kateri recalled a story from her father about a Native American chief who kept having boys even when he expected a girl. In homage to this tale, the chief named his eleventh son “Sheyboygan” because “She’s a boy again.” Inspired by this unique name, Jay and Kateri decided to use “Sheyboygan” as Finley’s middle name.

Now, Finley joins his brothers Tyler (25), Zach (22), Drew (21), Brandon (19), Tommy (16), Vinny (15), Calvin (12), Gabe (11), Wesley (9), Charlie (8), Luke (6), Tucker (4), and Francisco (2) in the Schwandt family. Although they had hoped for a little sister, the couple and their sons are thrilled to welcome another boy into their loving clan.

As Jay Schwandt puts it, “We’re just as excited with number 14 as we were with number one. It’s something we really enjoy, and the boys have such a good time with it.” And if anyone ever gives Finley a hard time about his unique name, he can count on his 13 brothers to have his back. After all, they’re a tight-knit crew who have each other’s back through thick and thin.

So, while Finley Sheyboygan Schwandt might have an unusual name, he also has an incredible story to tell. And with his loving family by his side, he’ll always have the support and protection he needs.